Most Indianapolis Colts fans have heard by now the controversy-causing words this week of former New England Patriots CB Rodney Harrison.

Harrison, who played 15 NFL seasons before announcing his retirement Wednesday, was on a conference call shortly afterward with former Colts Head Coach Tony Dungy. The pair was being introduced as the newest members of the broadcast team for NBC’s Football Night in America. On the call, the topic turned to Colts quarterback Peyton Manning’s recent comments expressing frustration over uncertainty on the Indianapolis coaching staff. Said Harrison:

This is something I’ve discussed with Coach Dungy and I think it’s what really gives Tom Brady the edge over Peyton Manning in terms of leadership, because he’s a guy that if this went on in New England, he wouldn’t come out publicly and he wouldn’t make a big fuss about it. I think as a leader on a team, you being Peyton Manning, a [future] Hall of Famer, you need to keep it in house. You have so many guys looking up to you and once they see the panic on your part, then all of a sudden they start getting nervous. I have a lot of respect for Peyton Manning but this is a guy at times that needs to control his emotions and not allow these things that should stay in house, get outside of those walls.

Dungy said he didn’t think Manning was panicked and Harrison replied:

But as a player your job is to play football; you can’t control some of the political aspects of what’s going on and I know Peyton is frustrated, but you have to understand this is OTAs, not even mini camp yet so there is no sense of panic yet, it’s still early. These things can be worked out. I mean he has been running this offense for 11 years, it’s not like it’s new to him. It just disappointed me being that it’s so early in the off-season that he would come out publicly and say these things. For him to publicly come out and publicly get upset like that I just thought it was a sense of panic.

Two thoughts here:

One is that this is the difference between someone with insight and someone with an observation, and too often broadcasters — particularly new ones — don’t know or care about the difference. Two is that maybe Harrison wanted to say something controversial to establish himself as a pertinent voice, the reality was there was a big difference between how Manning’s words sounded than how they read last week. If all you did was read Manning’s comments, you could see how Harrison might interpret them that way, but most people who listened to Manning speak almost had to have heard more short-term frustration and annoyance than panic.

I’ll again say what I said last week and that’s that I can’t shake this idea that all of this talk is much ado about very about very little. I can’t see Tom Moore and Howard Mudd — the two most uncertain coached around the staff — not coaching in a big-time role next season, and once that happens, you figure Manning’s annoyance will fade to memory.

Should Manning necessarily have said what he said? Perhaps not. Would the Colts have preferred he not said what he said? That probably goes without saying, but in the big picture, the truest thing Harrison said was that it’s still early and these things can be worked out.

This, obviously, was a predictable occurrence when NBC hired Harrison. He’s a controversial, outspoken guy who for a while at least will make for good TV. For him to pass on a chance to stir it up with the Colts would have been out of character. And Harrison’s words undoubtedly will be rehashed when the Colts and Patriots play on NBC on November 15, and must-see TV.

But beyond on occasional television rehash, I’d still be surprised if this issue carries much past the offseason.

Tagged with:
 

6 Responses to “Surprise, surprise: Former New England Patriots S Rodney Harrison weighs in on Manning”

  1. colt44 says:

    Who would’ve ever guessed an ex-Patriot jumping on Manning the first chance he gets ….no way!

    Honestly, when I guy that played for a team that got caught cheating, who himself was labeled as the NFL’s dirtiest player and not least of all got caught himself using an banned substance. He has no credibility at all and can’t be taken seriously. I’m glad he retired and I’m also glad he made note the Manning will be a future hall of famer, because that’s one thing ROID-ney Harrison won’t be.

  2. the_iowa_hawkeye says:

    The idea of Rodney Harrison calling ANYONE out for something that is untoward is beyond hypocrisy.

  3. colt44 says:

    I’m definitely not looking forward to seeing ROID-ney on the Sunday night broadcast.

  4. csmith says:

    I can’t believe NBC even hired him. This would be like hiring Jose Canseco and Barry Bonds to join Peter Gammons on Baseball Tonight.

  5. A.J. says:

    Ignoring who said it – because what’s already been posted says all that needs to be said about Harrison, and I agree with every single bit of it – isn’t this story really overblown? What has Manning said that damn near all of us haven’t about our own workplaces at one time or another? Sure, people can talk about keeping things in house, not criticizing your organization, blah blah blah, but I’m just flabbergasted that this is being treated by some like the early days of the Culter-in-Denver fiasco. Manning vented a little, not a lot. Frankly, Vince Young’s statements were more incendiary than Mannings were, and in my mind were getting equal coverage.

    Too many rushing to judge, to few just sitting back and observing in this issue. It’s like pro football has reached the level where every bit of minituae is analyzed obsessively. Peyton’s talk means nothing in the end; it’s just a venting. People should leave him be; actions speak louder than words, and it’s not like he’s refused to meet with the owners, boycotted OTAs, or talked about getting traded. On the contrary, he’s there leading and working his tail off. That is a far bigger statement than the one that came out of his mouth back then, and means a lot more. But of course, is ignored by 9/10ths of the non-Colts NFL viewing public (*rolls eyes*).

  6. [...] The Indy Football Report – Surprise, surprise: Former New England … [...]



Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes