In the first of a position-by-position series, Indy Football Report Editor John Oehser takes a look at the quarterbacks Indianapolis Colts roster after the 2009 NFL Draft.
The Depth Chart . . . .
1) Peyton Manning, 12th season, Tennessee: 371-555 completions, 4,002 yards, 27 touchdowns, 12 interceptions, 95.0 rating. . . . NFL Most Valuable Player. . . . Pro Bowl selection.
2) Jim Sorgi, sixth season, Wisconsin: 22-30 completions, 178 yards, 0 touchdowns, 0 interceptions, 87.9 rating.
3) Curtis Painter, rookie, Purdue.
4) Chris Crane, rookie, Boston College.
The front line . . .
The Colts are obviously as good here as any team in the NFL. Manning recovered from preseason knee surgery last season to have one of the most remarkable quarterbacking seasons in recent memory. He was particularly efficient over the second half of the season, playing withan aging Marvin Harrison at one wide receiver and behind an offensive line that dealt with injuries much of the season. Manning has had more statistically impressive seasons, but considering the circumstances, his 11thwas his best. An intriguing storyline entering ‘09 is how Manning will play with an entire offseason to condition, a healthy line and a receiving corps that no longer includes Harrison but includes an improving Anthony Gonzalez and an elite, sometimes-overlooked Reggie Wayne very much in his prime.
The depth . . .
Although backup QB Jim Sorgi often is the target for criticism and concern, the Colts like their depth at the position and never have wavered on their stance in six seasons that he is the backup. He played well in a season-ending, 23-0 victory over the Tennessee Titans this past season. When Sorgi has played in his five seasons, he typically has been efficient. Although fans and media often have clamored for a different backup, don’t forget: the Patriots were close to releasing Matt Cassel last season and he nearly took them to the playoffs before moving on to become the starter in Kansas City.
The offseason . . .
The Colts drafted Painter in the sixth round from Purdue University, a move that has caused much discussion in recent weeks among Colts fans. Colts President Bill Polian said Painter won’t push the veteran Sorgi for the backup position this season, but both Polian and Colts Jim Caldwell said they liked Painter’s protypical size, arm strength, accuracy as well as his ability to handle the Colts’ complex offense. The Colts on Monday also signed former Boston College quarterback Chris Crane as a collegiate free agent.
The immediate future . . .
Manning has said he’s nowhere close to retirement and Colts President Bill Polian said the team is nowhere near looking for a replacement.
Overview . . .
Look for the Colts to carry three quarterbacks next season, a move that would mark a departure from recent seasons, but one Polian and Caldwell each seemed open to after the draft. Manning is without question the franchise and will be for the foreseeable future, with Sorgi the clear backup for this season. Painter is an intriguing story, but one that should be viewed with perspective. Yes, the Colts would like him to develop into a big-time player, but there’s no guarantee that will happen, so don’t think they’re pushing Sorgi out the door. And as for those who theorize that the Colts might be grooming Painter to be Manning’s replacement, I just don’t see it. Grooming successors might work at other positions, or with lesser quarterbacks, but you don’t groom the replacement for a player of his stature while he’s still in his prime. More likely, Painter and Sorgi will compete for the backup job in 2010 at the earliest, and I still think the best-case scenario for the Colts is to hope Painter develops into a big-time prospect who can be traded for a prime draft selection in two or three years. Crane likely will be hard-pressed to make the roster.
In a sentence . . .
This is a position of obvious strength for the Colts, and although there is an obvious dropoff after Manning, the depth is better than most think.